MSG Team's other articles

10957 The Rent vs. Buy Decision

The rent vs. buy decision is as old as the concept of financial planning itself. There are people who have very strong views on both sides of the spectrum. There are some people who believe that owning a home is always better and that renting a house is like throwing money away. At the same […]

11708 Uber’s New Businesses

Uber is already a well-known brand across the world. Technically, the company is still a startup. However, Uber has a valuation of close to $70 billion. Also, the company is planning for an aggressive IPO. It is estimated that Uber’s post IPO valuation will be close to $120 billion. This is phenomenal given the fact […]

11447 The Sudden Downfall of IL&FS

The Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services (IL&FS) corporation were one of the bellwethers of India’s infrastructure sector. Ever since the government started pushing for better infrastructure, IL&FS was one of the first companies to come into existence. This company is responsible for building thousands of kilometers of roads and several ports. This financial giant has […]

10828 Prospect Theory

Prospect Theory is probably the most important piece of literature in behavioral finance. The conclusions made in prospect theory underlie a lot of aversions and biases, which have been discussed in different articles. Hence, in order to understand all those biases and the behavioral finance theory in general, it is important to understand what the […]

12757 Circular References in Financial Modelling

A lot of financial modeling takes place in Microsoft Excel. One of the errors that financial modelers come across during the financial modeling process is called the “Circular Reference” error. This error can affect many values in any model. To an untrained financial modeler, this could be the source of a lot of panic. However, […]

Search with tags

  • No tags available.

In corporate finance we studied that companies had an option when it came to compensating their equity shareholders. They could both pay these shareholders cash dividends from the earnings of the current year or alternatively they could conduct a share repurchase program and buy back some shares from the same proceeds. The monetary effect would be the exact same. Differences, if any would arise because of the taxation policy of the particular country.

However, when it comes to valuation, there is a huge difference between cash dividends and share repurchase programs. However, some organizations prefer to conduct share repurchases. Hence, as an analyst it is important to understand how share repurchase affects the value of a company.

This article explains the same in great detail:

Why Share Repurchase May Be Difficult To Value?

  • Shares repurchase programs lead to a reduction in the number of shares outstanding. This is different because usually the number of shares remains constant. When the numbers of shares change, the “per share” valuation is also affected. This relationship is difficult to model and predict
  • It is an unwritten rule, that dividends once announced should not be cut by the corporations. However, when it comes to share repurchases, there is no such rule. Companies do not find themselves under any obligation to conduct share repurchase year after year. Therefore, dividends are systematic and predictable whereas share repurchase may be erratic.
  • There is almost always a direct correlation between earnings and dividend payout. This means that a higher profit automatically translates into a higher dividend. The same cannot be said about share repurchase. Share repurchase is driven by market price and the intention is to time the market. Hence companies may not indulge in share repurchase transactions even though they are flush with cash because they may believe that the share is overvalued at the current price. Once again, this creates unpredictability about the magnitude and timing of cash flows.

Therefore, share repurchase programs are not as reliable or as consistent as dividend payout programs. However, companies may indulge in these transactions and valuations have to be conducted.

How to Value Share Repurchases?

When dealing with share repurchase, the analyst may have to go beyond per share data. This is because the number of shares outstanding keeps on changing and hence per share data from last year may not be comparable to this year’s numbers. Here are the steps commonly followed while valuing share repurchases:

  • The total earnings of a company are first estimated. This is done in the same manner as it is done for dividend discount models
  • The amount of earnings that are to be paid out to investors is then determined. Once again the payout ratio could be obtained empirically or based on specific information that a company may have on hand
  • Thirdly, the market price of the shares outstanding at that time has to be forecasted. This is the difficult and subjective part. The bid that the company makes for its own shares has to be above the prevailing market price. But estimating future prices is very difficult and is prone to a large degree of error.
  • Lastly, using the amount of earnings to be distributed and the price per share, we can find out the number of shares that will be extinguished and therefore the new number of shares that will be outstanding.
  • Once this is known, the valuation of these outstanding shares can also be derived.

To sum it up, the procedure largely depends on forecasting what the share price will be in the future. In the near future, an educated guess is still possible. However, predicting the stock price 5 or 10 years hence is sheer speculation and it is for this reason that analysts face problems arriving at a valuation for companies which use share repurchase as a tool to reward equity shareholders

Article Written by

MSG Team

An insightful writer passionate about sharing expertise, trends, and tips, dedicated to inspiring and informing readers through engaging and thoughtful content.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Calculating Free Cash Flows: The Case of Preferred Shares

MSG Team

Calculating Free Cash Flow to Equity

MSG Team