The COSO Framework for Internal Control
February 12, 2025
Constant change is a norm in today’s fast-paced business environment. It’s become important for companies to respond almost immediately, in order to sustain in a business world where: Geographical boundaries are continually diminishing; Technology is rapidly advancing; Customer expectations are ever changing; and The whole world is 24/7 connected. Agility is one of the most […]
Various organizations have laid down principles for risk management. There are risk management principles by International standardization Organization and by Project Management Body of Knowledge. The Project management body of knowledge (PMBOK) has laid down 12 principles. This article carries an amalgamation of both PMBOK and ISO principles. The various principles are: Organizational Context: Every […]
There have been many advances in the field of credit management. Mark to market accounting is one such innovation. Mark to market accounting is now commonly used by many organizations to manage their credit risks. In this article, we will understand what the concept of mark to market is and how it helps in managing […]
The definition of operational risk has been narrowed down. This has helped organizations better manage their operational risks. All operational risks can now be traced to four basic causes viz. people, processes, systems, and external events. However, merely stating a risk as a systems risk does not provide too much information. There is no actionable […]
Long term memories last for a longer period of time as it has the capacity to store information for a relatively longer period of time and retrieve the same whenever required. Some of the important facts related to long term memory which should be known are provided below: Long term memories usually remain out of […]
Most of the literature in market risk management is dedicated to explaining the methods which are used in the management of regular market risk. This means that importance is rightly given to the management of the cases which are likely to occur 99% of the time. However, the recent past has shown us that there are some severe events that can happen 1% of the time.
For instance, the subprime mortgage crisis, as well as the coronavirus pandemic, are two severe events that have taken place over the course of a decade! If these infrequent but high-impact events are not managed in an appropriate manner, they could threaten the very existence of the firm. The risk which these unforeseen events pose to the organization is called tail risk. In this article, we will have a closer look at what tail risk is and how it can be used to manage risks better.
In simple words, tail risk is the risk of loss that may arise when a highly improbable event occurs. They are often called “black swan” events in reference to the term black swan which was coined by Nicholas Nassem Taleb.
The more technical definition of tail risk is that it is the risk arising from three standard deviations away from the mean. This means that if we assume a normal distribution, almost 99.7% of the values will be within three standard deviations from the mean. Hence, the risk arising from the balance of 0.3% of the values is called tail risk.
It needs to be understood that the approach used to manage tail risks is different from the approach used to manage the other risks. This is because of the fact that it is impossible to predict tail risk. This is the reason that no attempt is made to predict the black swan events as opposed to the other risk events. Instead, it is assumed that these events will take place infrequently and there must be a mechanism in place in order to manage the risk better.
In the above definition, we have assumed that the returns follow a normal distribution. However, in reality, that may not be the case. There are many statisticians who have observed that the returns seem to have more values towards the extreme left and extreme right end than a normal curve. This is colloquially referred to as a fat tail. Over the years, statisticians have developed a different type of distribution called the fat-tailed distribution in order to be able to manage these situations better.
Tail risks are generally managed by hedging these risks. There are several ways in which this hedging is done.
For instance, the investors can buy an option that allows them to sell their securities at a higher price if the value of these securities goes below a certain price. This price is the price that is three standard deviations away from the mean. Since the probability of this event happening is extremely low i.e. 0.3%, the options are quite cheap.
In most of the years, the options will be out of the money and hence it may appear like a waste of resources to continue buying them. However, one must not forget that the risk being covered is rare but has a huge impact. Hence, it is advisable to continue buying the options unabated.
There are certainly other strategies that are also used to hedge tail risk. For instance, firms can deliberately reduce the amount they invest in highly volatile sectors.
Alternatively, derivatives such as swaps can also be used. However, whenever derivatives are involved, the complexity of the instruments increases rapidly. Monitoring and mitigating risks become even more important since it may be possible to lose more than the initial investment which was made.
Many experts believe that hedging tail risks can be quite expensive. This may be true particularly when fat tails are being hedged. However, leaving the fat tails unhedged would be like taking a huge risk. Everything will work fine for a long period of time until one day when it suddenly doesn’t!
There are several benefits that are realized as a result of this hedging.
If we consider all these advantages, it may in fact be much more expensive to not hedge the tail risks particularly when the option premiums required for this protection may be paltry.
To sum it up, tail risks are not covered under the value at risk (VaR) model. They need to be calculated separately. Hedging is the only way to mitigate them since anticipating such risks is almost impossible.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *