Executive Pay: The Curious Case of Carlos Ghosn’s Arrest
February 12, 2025
Introduction Knowledge is very important for survival of organization. Historically, employees have gathered knowledge through trial-and-error method or by working as an apprentice under a tenured knowledgeable employee. Management guru Peter Drucker forwarded a concept that knowledge is as valuable as a company’s various asset like plant, machinery, etc. Importance of Knowledge Management Knowledge provides […]
Who are HNIs and Why They are Valuable to Businesses We often hear the term HNIs or High Net-worth Individuals mentioned in a wide variety of contexts. Whether it is bankers launching a new product aimed at these individuals, media outlets reporting on their private lives and covering the weddings and other events, or for […]
While Fredrick Taylor’s scientific management had help create huge American corporations that were quick to adopt the viewpoint, the 1970’s saw the emergence of Japanese corporations. These corporations were very small at the end of World War-2 when Japan had been economically devastated. However within two decades, a group of Japanese companies completely turned the […]
Farm Loan Waivers, Bank Bailouts, and Moral Hazards Farm Loan Waivers are the Flavor of the Season as Indian States take turns indulging in a game of who waives the maximum loans taken by the farmers. Indeed, with elections approaching, a form of Competitive Populism has begun wherein each political party is trying to outdo […]
Apart from accuracy and precision, there are more factors that determine the soundness of a measurement system. Two of these important factors are as follows: Resolution: Resolution is the ability to see fine details in a system. This ability also gives the system, the ability to distinguish different readings from one another. A good example […]
Planned obsolescence is often considered to be a part of the capitalist ideology. The supposed logic behind planned obsolescence is that capitalist companies put inferior components in their products.
As a result, these products do not last as long. Since the products break down sooner, the customers are forced to buy new products.
Opponents of capitalism, often cite planned obsolescence as the sort of evil that gets propagated as a result of capitalism. According to them, not only does planned obsolescence have economic costs but also environmental costs.
This practice has been vilified as being the reason why resources are wasted on such a large scale besides also burning a hole in the pockets of most consumers.
In this article, we will look at the other side. We will try to understand why planned obsolescence doesn’t really exist in reality, but is instead the figment of the imagination of commentators who hate capitalism.
As a result, the present value of their product in the eyes of the consumer will be less.
The company risks losing sales in the short run and even running out of business in the long run. Consumers will obviously prefer to buy from manufacturers who can make better and longer lasting products.
Critics often argue that companies have formed a cartel. As a result, all of them are using inferior components. This is the reason why no one produces a better product and takes away the market share. This explanation is implausible on several grounds. This would mean that thousands of companies, big and small, spread out across different geographies are somehow adhering to a pact.
Some of these companies have had very unprofitable years in the past, some have even gone bankrupt. Breaking the pact would have been a very profitable thing for them to do.
However, none of them seem to have done so! Hence, this whole idea that a cartel is somehow controlling the quality of the products is implausible.
Now, several groundbreaking technologies are introduced into the market every day. If one were to not innovate in the mobile phone market for a period of three years, they wouldn’t have a company by the end of it!
This is the reason why companies have to launch new products and new models several times a year. It is not feasible for them to manufacture one product which would be of best quality.
This is because the quality is not stagnant. As soon as a product is launched, the design of another product starts immediately.
Product lifecycles are becoming smaller. Once again, there is no cartel which is enforcing the timely obsolescence of products. Instead, it is the market which is causing the companies to change their products within increasingly shorter periods of time.
However, now it is common for cars to have as much as 300,000 miles on them. In fact, cars are seldom sold by their first owner before reaching 100,000 miles. The cars of today are clearly lasting longer than they did earlier.
If there were a cartel enforcing planned obsolescence, this would not be the case. The modern cars would be breaking down even before 100,000 miles.
Also, it needs to be noted that some car brands like Volvo and BMW take pride in making sturdier cars. It is common for their cars to run for as long as 500,000 miles.
If there was a cartel in operation, why would it allow some companies to make longer lasting cars while restricting the others?
Volvo and BMW do receive a premium for the longevity of their cars. Wouldn’t the other cartel members object to this preferential treatment? It is not possible for the manufacturer of every major product to somehow collude with all the other major players and together create a mega cartel.
Such a cartel would not live long because of the immense infighting. Remember that all of these companies are competitors and each one gains at the expense of the others.
The reality is that the concept of planned obsolescence does not really exist in reality. It is only a bogeyman that has been created by the government and other agencies to shake down and extort money from innovative businessmen.
It is up to the person to realize that the free market system with all its flaws is also much more efficient than the centrally planned state that was created by countries like USSR.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *