MSG Team's other articles

9298 Falling Gender Ratio and Ways to Prevent the Decline in Numbers of Women

While the gender ratio was hovering around 930-950 throughout the earlier decades when there were fewer women than men as a statistical fact, this has become more alarming in recent years because the number is falling rapidly. When taken together with the overall increase in population of India that has a large percentage of young […]

11202 Scenario Analysis in Risk Management

Scenario analysis is the third pillar of the framework suggested by the Bank of International Settlements in their Basel norms. In the previous articles, we have already studied a collection of internal and external loss data as well as the self-assessment of risks. However, it is important to note that the loss data collection framework […]

9024 Driving Organizational Change by Embracing Agile and Facing the VUCA World

What is Agile and what is meant by the VUCA World? It is hard not to miss the extensive press coverage for the Agile Methodology that is taking the corporate world by storm. Indeed, this innovative, flexible, and adaptable way of doing things and ordering work has been credited by leading business leaders for its […]

12118 How to Handle Conflict of Interest in Corporate Settings

What is Conflict of Interest and how does it arise? In recent months, we have seen a spate of scandals involving top corporate houses and sportspersons about how they have been implicated in conflict of interest issues. These scandals have dented the reputations of many corporate houses, media houses, and sports management companies. At heart […]

11336 Social Stratification and Hierarchy: What Business Leaders Ought to Know

Rise above Social Stratification All societies are stratified and have elements of hierarchy amongst their members. If the notion of Varna or Caste is prevalent in the East, then the notion of class and race is prevalent in the west. In recent decades, with the advent of modernity and postmodernism, there has been a tendency […]

Search with tags

  • No tags available.

Conflict of interest scenarios are common in businesses where multiple parties are involved. In many cases, these conflicts are small and harmless. However, when it comes to insurance, some of these conflicts turn out to be serious. In this article, we will have a look at the various situations in which the different participants related to the insurance industry face these conflicts.

Some of the situations have been listed below:

  1. The Commission Structure: All across the world, insurance products are distributed by a network of agents. These agents are paid remunerations based on the sales they make, i.e. they receive a commission.

    The problem is that some insurance products offer more commission than the others. Also, some insurance service providers also more commission than the others. Hence, there is a likelihood that an insurance agent may face a conflict of interest situation. In many cases, the policy that is best for the policyholder may not be the most profitable one for the insurance agent.

    In order to solve this problem of inherent conflict of interest, it has been recommended that the commission based pay structure be dismantled. Instead, the price of the insurance products should be reduced, and individuals should be made to pay a fee to insurance agents when using their services.

    However, it has been observed that a fee-based structure leads to dropped sales as people are averse to making such payments. This is the reason that the United Kingdom is the only country in the world where insurance agents receive remuneration from customers.

    In all other countries, this model is considered to be a failure. It has been proposed that the commission for different insurance products by different insurance companies in the same genre must be homogenized in order to avoid such conflicts. However, until now, no action has been taken to that effect.

  2. Service Providers: In case of general insurance, service providers, i.e. partners of insurance companies are the ones who face the maximum conflict of interest. Let’s understand this with the help of an example.

    For instance, when a car meets with an accident, the garage, i.e. the service provider is required to repair the car. The insurance company has to pay the bill, on behalf of the customer, to the garage.

    The problem is that since the customer is not paying out of his own pocket, he/she does not seem to care too much about the bill. In such scenarios, service providers face a conflict. They could easily inflate a bill and maximize their returns. However, if they do so, they will be acting against the best interests of their partner, i.e. the insurance company. This issue is not limited to car insurance alone.

    It is a known fact that hospitals perform unnecessary procedures on insured patients. This helps them inflate the bill and earn more even though it is done at the expense of everyone else.

    In case of medical insurance, it is very difficult to prevent these activities. However, for motor insurance, companies appoint independent surveyors and in-house personnel whose job is to ascertain the degree of loss. To some extent, this has helped reduce the inherent conflict of interest. However, this situation is also not foolproof, and insurance companies are continuously trying to find new methods to prevent such situations from arising.

    For instance, many insurance companies offer lower premiums when customers opt for policies where there are provisions for co-pay. Hence, if the total bill is inflated, the customer’s contribution also ends up being inflated. As a result, there is no motivation to make inflated claims and customers start paying more attention to what services are being provided and whether a fair price is being charged for them.

  3. State Owned Insurance Companies: In many parts of the world, it is common for the state to own a significant share in the dominant insurance player. This is the case because, in many countries, insurance companies were earlier owned by the state. Later, privatization happened, and other companies were allowed to sell insurance.

    However, if the government is also a player in the market, while simultaneously being a regulator, there is an obvious conflict of interest. It is likely that the government may create regulations to harm the interests of other players or even the consumers. Hence, to avoid such conflicts of interest, it is extremely important that the government divest its interests in insurance companies and take a backseat when it comes to running them.

The bottom line is that conflicts of interests are here to stay. It is just how the game is structured. However, the problem is that most buyers are not made aware that such conflicts do exist. Hence, they end up acting in a naíve manner while buying insurance. Educating customers is of utmost importance since that is the only way that their interests can be safeguarded.

Article Written by

MSG Team

An insightful writer passionate about sharing expertise, trends, and tips, dedicated to inspiring and informing readers through engaging and thoughtful content.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

The COSO Framework for Internal Control

MSG Team

The Cost Structure in the Insurance Industry

MSG Team

Credit Derivatives: An Introduction

MSG Team