Conflict of Interest in Investment Banking
February 12, 2025
The price to earnings ratio is the most fundamental of all market related ratios. It has been used for decades by stalwarts in the investment community. However, it is also the ratio that has come under maximum fire from the skeptics. A variety of measurements have been developed to compensate for what skeptics call the […]
Now, since we are aware that there are actually multiple models that can be used to value any given company or asset, the next question that arises is which one should we use? How do we know whether a given valuation model is more appropriate for a given company than the others? The answer is […]
Reserve requirements are one of the most important features of modern central banking. We hear about reserve requirements almost every day in the media. When central banks like the Fed change these requirements, it is said to have a huge impact on the markets. Liquidity worth billions of dollars is said to be either released […]
The Glitz and Glamour of Finance Beckons Many Many management graduates and those working towards entering business schools often aspire to be financial professionals and dream of being an investment banker, private equity specialist, stock analyst, or a pure play banker in the plain vanilla banking. Indeed, with the globalization of finance and the integration […]
“Cash is King” say the bigwigs on Wall Street. That is why the valuation of shares is done on the basis of discounted cash flow model rather than discounted earnings model. The price to cash flow ratio provides an analyst with a shortcut for finding companies that have been undervalued in comparison to their cash […]
In many cases, IPOs are thought of as being underpriced. This means that as soon as the IPO is listed in the market, investor demand appears, and as a result, the price of the newly listed shares goes up. This is the situation that the issuing company, as well as the investment banker, wants to be in. This is because it creates customer satisfaction amongst the investment community, and they will be inclined towards buying into future issues by the issuing company as well as the investment banker.
However, in some cases, the prices of the newly issued shares start going down. This could be due to external factors such as the overall state of the economy. In such cases, investors often tend to be dissatisfied with the results. Hence, in order to prevent this, a strategy called the greenshoe option is exercised by the investment bankers. In this article, we will understand what the greenshoe option is and what is accomplished by utilizing this option.
Greenshoe option gives special powers to the “stabilizing agent” appointed by the issuing company. In most cases, the lead investment banker is appointed as the “stabilizing agent.” As per these powers, the investment banker has the option of issuing up to 15% additional shares as compared to the initial issue. This means that if the initial issue was determined to be for 10000 shares, the investment bankers could create as many as 1500 additional shares. Hence, a total of 11500 shares are issued to the retail investors in the market. These shares are also allocated to the investors on a pro-rata basis.
However, from the point of view of the company, the money received from the sale of 10000 shares is put into the equity account. On the other hand, the money received from the sale of these additional 1500 shares is kept in a separate stabilizing account. This account is not controlled by the company but is instead controlled by the investment banker. The idea is that the money in this account is to be kept as a reserve. If the price of the shares starts falling below the issue price, this money will be used by the investment bankers to start buying shares in the open market. This will lead to an increase in demand, which would mean that the price of the shares would also go up.
Before the company goes public, it would have to inform the investors that a greenshoe option has been given to the investment bankers. Also, it would have to mention the stabilization period for which this option is to be exercised. The stabilization period cannot exceed 30 days. This means that at the end of 30 days, the investment bankers will no longer be authorized to trade on behalf of the issuing company in order to stabilize their prices.
The greenshoe option begins by borrowing up to 15% additional shares from the promoters. The lock-in period regulations are not applicable to the greenshoe option. Hence, promoters can lend their shares even though they are within the lock-in period. The process can end in one of the three ways depending upon the market conditions:
A greenshoe option is a powerful tool in the hand of the investment banker. As seen above, the banker can use the money to buy back the shares in case of a short position. However, if the prices go on increasing, there is no compulsion for them to buy any shares and return the promoters. Thus, the investment banker is equipped to protect the company from attacks by bearish investors. The final decision regarding the quantum of shares to be bought back, as well as the price at which they have to be bought back, are left to the investment banker.
The bottom line is that the greenshoe option is an exceptional strategy which is used by investment banks to help the newly issued shares to be stabilized in the short run.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *