The Chinese Pension System
February 12, 2025
In the previous articles, we have learned about how the money market is just like any other financial market. This means that just like other markets, speculators also form a significant portion of investors in the money market. As a result, the money market also has a certain amount of volatility just like other markets. […]
In the previous article we learned that free cash flow to the firm is closely related to the concept of cash flow from operations. The major difference was in the way free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) treats long term capital expenditures versus how they get treated in the regular cash flow statement. The […]
Portfolio management refers to the art of managing various financial products and assets to help an individual earn maximum revenues with minimum risks involved in the long run. Portfolio management helps an individual to decide where and how to invest his hard earned money for guaranteed returns in the future. Portfolio Management Models Capital Asset […]
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis is the bedrock of modern-day financial analysis. It is for this reason that financial modelers use discounted cash flow analysis extensively. In fact, the DCF analysis may have been the reason why the field of financial modeling came into existence in the first place. In this article, we will have […]
The capital budgeting process is at the heart of the financial decision-making which takes place in any organization. However, up until now, the capital budgeting decision has been considered to be a financial decision. As a result, the evaluation of projects and the capital allocation process are based on discounted cash flow analysis. Many organizations […]
The past couple of decades has seen tectonic shifts in the way pension plans are being funded. Investors all over the world have been encouraged to shift from defined benefit pension plans to defined contribution pension plans. In the past, defined contribution plans were not considered to be pension plans at all. Instead, defined contribution plans were considered to be supplementary savings plans. Hence, it has been difficult to convince investors about the need to move on to defined contribution plans.
In this article, we will have a closer look at the various pros and cons of defined contribution plans as well as the various ways in which they affect the average worker.
However, the modern employee is more mobile. They do not want to work in the same company for a significant amount of time. Instead, they want to change employers frequently so that they can be paid competitive wages.
Defined contribution plans are not employer-specific. Whenever a person leaves an organization, they can simply take their retirement benefits to the new employer. There are some barriers like vesting schedules which may impact the amount of pension which is transferred to the new employer. However, for the most part, defined contribution plans have much more mobility.
However, the defined contribution plans are market-linked. Hence, the investor is himself/herself responsible for the performance of such plans. The taxpayer is not bound to pay for the shortfall in any circumstances.
The problem with this approach is that the birth rate is falling in most countries. Hence, newer employees would have to pay higher contributions to enable payments to older beneficiaries. The defined contribution plan invests the money paid in by employees and pays out the proceeds of the same. Hence, it is not affected by government underfunding.
In most cases, the investment policy would be the same across all participating employees. This meant that old, as well as young employees, invested their money in the same manner. Since companies wanted to be conservative, this generally meant that a large portion of the money was invested in low-yield instruments which were considered to be very safe. The end result of this exercise was that the rate of return owned by pension funds was very low.
Defined contribution pension plans have changed this situation. Such plans give individuals the choice to decide on their asset classes based on their risk appetite. Defined contribution pension plans allow investors to decide their asset allocation on a yearly basis. Hence, employees who are young can choose to invest more in equities whereas older employees can choose a more balanced portfolio. This allocation can also be changed every year based on market conditions as well as changing the financial needs of the employees.
The end result of this freedom and choice is that investors have a chance to earn a higher yield on their investments. Also since pension funds are held for very long, the law of compounding drastically increases the overall corpus even if the annual yield is increased by a couple of percentage points.
The bottom line is that a defined contribution pension plan has many advantages. If properly utilized, it can help employees create a much bigger retirement corpus as compared to defined benefit contribution plans.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *