The Chinese Pension System
February 12, 2025
Cash flows vary from project to project. In some cases cash flows will occur evenly over time. There might be payments of similar amounts that will be spread out over a time period at regular intervals. On the other hand, there might be payments which are irregular and have no pattern whatsoever. The challenge in […]
The discipline of economics is generally valid for all industries across the world. This is because the basic fundamental economic principles of demand, supply, and free market are applicable to almost all industries in the world. There are only a few industries where these economic principles are not really applicable. The sporting industry is one […]
The gist of optimism bias is often expressed by using the popular saying “rose-tinted glasses.” In real life, it is helpful to be an optimist. Optimists often live happier and healthier lives. However, when it comes to financial markets, a healthy dose of skepticism is not only necessary but also recommended by many experts. In […]
Public private partnership is a widely used model when it comes to infrastructure financing. However, it needs to be understood that not all public private partnerships end successfully. In some cases, the partnership ends in a default. This means that either one of the parties’ viz. the private party or the public party are unable […]
The derivative market can seem like a world unto itself. The market is so large and so different from the other markets that it has its own language. A new person trying to trade derivatives may not even understand the information that is being offered to them. It is therefore necessary to understand the vocabulary […]
In the previous articles, we have studied what a risk-based supervisory system for pension funds is. We have also studied the various steps which need to be taken in order to set up such a system.
It is true that this system is being adopted on a large scale worldwide because of the various benefits that it offers. However, it is also true that there are some significant challenges with this system.
It would be a huge mistake for pension fund regulators to only focus on the positives and implement the system without truly understanding the challenges involved in the process.
Some of the important challenges related to the implementation and management of a risk-based supervisory system have been mentioned in detail below:
Pension fund regulators have to sift through thousands of data points and indicators to zero down on a few which can explain the risk levels of the entire system. Once the pension fund supervision model has been created, it might appear to be very simple to implement. However, the reality is that there is a considerable amount of complexity that needs to be managed while creating the system.
Fortunately, many such systems have already been created across the world. Hence, newer systems can be created with less effort by adapting these systems to the local standards.
Almost all the risks which are faced by the system are correlated to each other. Sometimes these correlations are positive whereas other times these correlations are negative. This means that as per the risk-based supervisory system when an attempt is made to aggregate the risks, a huge operational challenge is created.
Some risks get amplified when aggregated at a systemic level whereas other risks get reduced while doing so. The bottom line is that aggregation of risks can be quite challenging.
The regulator may not have real-time access to the data. Even if they do have access to the data, the data may not be structured in the proper format. As a result, aggregating the data in a format that can be used for analysis can be quite challenging for the regulator.
Also, in many parts of the world, there might be data privacy concerns that make the transfer of such data difficult. Hence, it must be understood that having a fully functional data management system is a prerequisite to the implementation of a risk-based supervisory system.
There is no point in transferring historical data since the regulators cannot really use the same to undertake any preventive steps. The pension fund regulators have to constantly ensure that every data point and every decision being made is done with a focus on the future.
Firstly, it requires the participation and co-operation of people across various organizations. Hence, organizational boundaries have to be blurred and data sharing mechanisms have to be set up.
Another challenge is the fact that the resultant organization structure must allow for regulatory action to take place at a quick pace. However, at the same time, the need to provide accurate data is very high.
For instance, if there are gaps in the information flow between the participant company and the supervisor, it needs to be identified and corrected as soon as possible. Similarly, if there is a gap in the way credit scoring is done, some risks could be completely missed out.
In such cases, the pension fund regulator has to be intelligent enough to recognize these gaps and fix them in a timely manner. The inability to do so could prove expensive to the regulator and to the pension system as a whole.
Hence, even if implementing a risk-based supervisory system is beneficial, it is not an easy task. There are several challenges that need to be overcome before such a system starts providing the expected benefits.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *