MSG Team's other articles

12420 Bears in the Bond Market

If certain high profile fund managers and bond investors are to be believed, then the bond market has just slipped into a bear market. They are not talking about the usual tightening of the Fed’s interest rates. Interest rates have risen several times over the past few years. However, every time they return to normal. […]

10698 Present Value and Future Value of Money

Value of Money Depends Upon Time In the previous article we learned about the concept of nominal and real values of money. We realized that money today is more valuable than the same sum received at a future date because there is no risk involved in obtaining it and also the real value of money […]

8984 Valuation of Sports Franchises: Discount Rate Calculation

In the previous article, we have already seen how the valuation of a sporting franchise can be found using the income approach. This approach relies extensively on finding out the cash flow that is likely to accrue to the sporting franchise and then discounting it at a predetermined discount rate in order to find out […]

11193 Sample Size Neglect

Stock investments are supposed to be made based on rational choices. In this module, we have so far learned that investors are not exactly rational and tend to become emotional a lot of times. However, it is important to note that there are some cases in which investors are pretending to be rational but are […]

10055 Issues With Sponsorship Levels

In the previous article, we have already seen what sponsorship tiers or sponsorship levels are. We have also seen the various benefits that such a sponsorship arrangement can provide to both the sponsor as well as the sponsored sports entity. Hence, we know why sponsorship levels are widely used as a financing arrangement across various […]

Search with tags

  • No tags available.

The dividend discount model makes a lot of assumptions. Some of these assumptions are not considered to be viable by analysts. For instance, consider the assumption regarding growth rates. During the horizon period, the analyst estimates that the growth rate will be high, let’s say 10% or 12%. Then, when the terminal value is to be calculated, the estimate if of a lower return that will continue till perpetuity. Let’s say, a 5% rate is assumed.

To many critics, this seems like a critical flaw. They believe it to be an absurd assumption that a firm will make a 12% return in the 5th year and then suddenly the return will drop to 5% from the 6th year onwards. They believe that this assumption is absurd and use empirical analysis to prove that this is almost never the case.

Also, since the dividend discount model formula is extremely sensitive to assumptions regarding growth rates, they believe that the resultant valuation is quite a bit off the mark.

Therefore, to overcome this limitation, they have created a modified dividend discount model called the “H” model. In this article, we will take a closer look at what the H model is all about.

The H Model

The H model assumes that the earnings and dividends of the firm do not suddenly fall off a cliff when the horizon period ends. Rather, the decline in the growth rate is a gradual process. The assumption that the H model makes about this decline is that the decline is linear.

Hence instead of suddenly dropping from 12% to 5%, the growth rates will start declining from 12% at a given rate, let’s say 10% every year. Hence, from 12% the rate will drop to 10.8% and then in the next period to 9.7% and so on. This decline would then continue until it reaches the long term growth rate of 5%. Once the 5% growth rate is reached, it stabilizes over there and remains in that state until perpetuity.

The Formula

The derivation formula for calculating growth using the H growth rate requires some complex mathematics which is beyond the scope of this article. Hence, for our understanding, let’s just have a look at the formula and memorize it.

table.formulaTable{border:1px solid black;/*border:none;*/text-align:center;}table.formulaTable td{text-align:center;padding:5px;spacing:5px;}table.formulaTable td.numerator{border-bottom: solid 1px black;}
Value of A Share (H Model) = D0 * (1+gL)+D0 * H * (gS-gL)
r-gLr-gL

where,

  • D0 is the dividend received in the present year, let’s assume the value to be $25
  • R is the rate of return expected by the investor, let’s say 8% in this case
  • gL is the long term growth rate i.e. 5% in this case
  • gS is the short term growth rate i.e. 12% in this case
  • H is the half-life of the high growth period i.e. our high growth period was 5 years, therefore the value of H is 2.5 for our purpose.

Calculation

Value of A Share (H Model) = $25*(1+0.05)+$25 * 2.5 * (0.12-0.05)
0.08-0.050.08-0.05

= $875 + $145.833

= $1020.33

Interpretation:

  • The first component of the valuation i.e. $875 in this case is what the value of the shares would be if there was no high growth period at all. Notice that the formula is quite similar to the Gordon Growth model formula
  • The second component i.e. $145.33 is the addition in value resulting from the high growth period for 5 years. This component is where the H model differs from other dividend discount models

Accuracy of the Model

Empirical analysis has shown that the H model is most accurate when:

  • The high growth period is shorter i.e. the model would be less accurate if we assumed a 20 year high growth period instead of a 5 year high growth period
  • Also, the accuracy of the model increases when the spread between the long term growth rate and the short term growth rate is less

To conclude, the H model is a significant advancement in the field of equity valuation. It solves the problem of the abrupt decline in the growth rates that is assumed by the other models. However, it still provides only an estimate, albeit a better estimate than dividend discount models regarding the valuation of the stock.

Article Written by

MSG Team

An insightful writer passionate about sharing expertise, trends, and tips, dedicated to inspiring and informing readers through engaging and thoughtful content.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Calculating Free Cash Flows: The Case of Preferred Shares

MSG Team

Calculating Free Cash Flow to Equity

MSG Team