The Case against Free College Tuition
The Green New Deal proposal announced by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez suddenly became a talking point in American politics. The United States was visibly split into two camps, one was of people who are supporting the socialistic ideas being purported by the Democrat leader whereas others who oppose her plan. In a rather surprising development, large swathes […]
How to Create and Read a Pareto Chart ?
How to Create a Pareto Chart ? A Pareto chart is one of the 7 basic tools of quality control. It is for this reason that every student of quality management needs to know how to prepare and how to read a quality chart. The procedure for the same has been listed below: Step 1: […]
Information System for Recruitment and Selection
Introduction Human resource is one of the pillars which defines a strong and successful organization. Workforce is the backbone of any organization and form integral part of its strategic plans and initiatives. Recruitment and Selection Recruitment and selection are two of the main function carried out by human-resource department. An organization undertakes recruitment under following […]
Globalization and the Trickle Down Theory: Does it Work ?
The underlying premise behind globalization is that the transfer of wealth from the developed countries to the developing countries would eventually result in a scenario where those at the bottom of the ladder in the developing countries would benefit from the wealth flowing into their economies. The theory behind this is that if a Billion […]
Logistics Service Providers keeps Supply Chain Moving
Procurement Logistics, Manufacturing Logistics and Finished Goods Logistics functions are managed by different independent departments in a company. Though the duties of the departments involve common activities like transportation etc., however, the processes and nature of logistics functions are specific to each function besides the requirements and sensitivities of delivery times, schedules, etc. With the […]
The world media was recently rocked by a data breach scandal involving Facebook. This scandal wherein Facebook had allowed a third party named Cambridge Analytica to misuse the information of its users created a ruckus. Various campaigns broke out, and activists wanted to ensure that the integrity of the user’s data was not compromised by big tech firms like Facebook.
One of the suggestions provided by activists was that the ownership of the user’s data should lie with the users themselves and not with companies like Facebook. If the ownership lies with the users, Facebook would not be allowed to transmit this information to other parties without the user’s consent. Also, Facebook could share monetary compensation with the users in order to convince them to share some of their data which may not be very intrusive.
There was a widespread belief that this legislation would be able to solve the problem related to data misuse by tech giants. However, it turns out that this problem is not so easy to solve. In this article, we will have a closer look at why the “own your data” movement is not a feasible option.
At the present moment, Facebook owns all the data that its users generate on its website. This means that the images, content and even contacts that you have on Facebook are actually legally the property of Facebook. This is mentioned in the terms and conditions of their agreement which users generally do not read.
At the present moment, this also means that if users delete their personal information from Facebook, the company does not necessarily have to delete it from its own servers. Hence, you could log off Facebook, and the company would still have access to some of your private data for some time.
The concept of ownership is derived from the physical world. Goods are owned by people. Ownership means the exclusive right to access a property. This means that others are not allowed to access the same property. However, information transmission does not follow the same rules. When information is transmitted, a new person or entity now has access to that information. However, that does not mean that the old entity ceases to have access to that information. The concept of ownership is therefore difficult to enforce when it comes to data. Even if the government does create laws restricting the transfer of data and giving ownership rights to individuals, this right will be impossible to enforce in real life situations.
Laws need to be implemented by a certain court. For this, it is important that the issue should be under the jurisdiction of a particular court. The problem with the internet is that it has no boundaries. This means that information can flow freely to one or many countries across the world. As a result, enforcing an “own your data” policy would mean getting all other countries on the same page as well. Otherwise, tech firms will just move their operations to another company where it would be legal to collect and mine consumer data. Any legislation is likely to be extremely complex because it will have to supersede a complex web of regional, national and international legislations. The decisions taken by the courts will not be enforceable because the offending party may not be physically present with the jurisdiction of the courts.
Most democracies across the world believe in the concept of free speech. However, the problem is that privacy laws are opposed to the concept of free speech. Privacy laws restrict what can be spoken and written about. Hence, privacy laws can also be used as a shield to censor free press. This is the reason why Supreme Courts around the world are unlikely to enforce stricter privacy laws even after the Facebook debacle.
The data privacy issue is built into the business model at Facebook. This is because the company has no other source of revenue apart from selling the information of users. Hence, if users really want to get rid of the privacy issue, they should urge Facebook to provide them with an ad-free model. Many companies have a “freemium” model. As per this model, users are given a choice as to whether they want to see display ads or not. If they are willing to tolerate display ads, they can use the service for free. However, their data becomes the property of the company. On the other hand, they can pay a fee and prevent the company from using their data or seeing any advertisements.
At the present moment, the focus is on ensuring that Facebook does not toe the line. However, sooner or later, the company may be found trying to harvest the data in a way which many consider unethical.
Also, one needs to remember that Facebook is a big and powerful corporation with deep pockets. Given their ability to buy influence in Washington, it is highly unlikely that there will be any significant changes to the company’s operating model. However, incidents like these are definitely creating a negative image for Facebook.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
What the Current Wave of Protectionism and Populism mean for the Future of Globalization and Free Trade
February 12, 2025
