China’s Predatory Lending
February 12, 2025
The Icelandic budget airline “Wow airline” became the latest airline to go bankrupt in Europe. Of late, Europe has seen a lot of airlines go bankrupt due to multiple reasons. No less than eight airlines have suspended their operations in Europe in the past year. Price wars, rise in fuel prices, and overcapacity have been […]
Acqui-hire is a different type of acquisition strategy which has come into existence with the emergence of technology-based start-ups. For many start-up companies, employees are now their biggest assets. Hence, it should not be surprising that other companies may want to acquire this employee base to meet their own business needs. Hence, if a tech […]
Now, it’s time to move on to the second metric which can be used to derive the free cash flow to the firm (FCFF). This metric is the cash flow from operations. These types of questions involve a complete cash flow statement being provided as the question and expect the student to derive free cash […]
The world has seen many unconventional start-ups. However, almost all start-up companies derive their revenue from the earth. It is Elon Musk’s SpaceX that has opened up the investing community to a different dimension. Most of the businesses SpaceX is running and plans to run are related to outer space. Research related to outer space […]
Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) is the latest buzzword in the retail industry. The media has been full of debates about the benefits and drawbacks of Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) from the consumers point of view. However, when it comes to the point of view of the merchant or the seller, there has not […]
Indian banking sector is divided into two. There are public sector banks, and then there are private sector banks. The public sector banks, i.e., banks owned by the government are known as bureaucratic organizations where inefficiency is rampant. However, these banks are also known to be prone to corruption. This is because executives at state-owned banks are often under pressure to discard lending norms and guidelines. Politicians often ask these banks to give loans to their cronies even if they do not meet the required norms and standards.
There have been several scams that have taken place in the Indian banking system. However, the recent one has been the biggest in size. Punjab National Bank, i.e., a state-owned Indian bank is said to have lost more than Rs. 11,300 crore or $1.7 billion in this scam. This scam happened when an Indian businessman named Nirav Modi colluded with bank executives to swindle huge sums of money from the banking system.
In this article, we will have a closer look at the scam and how it was possible despite banks having systems, checks, and balances in place.
A letter of undertaking (LOU) is a mechanism to secure overseas credit for importing goods and services. When an importer buys goods, they need to make payment to an overseas bank on behalf of the exporter. Sometimes, they may not have the funds to do so. In such cases, they can ask a domestic bank to issue a letter of undertaking. This letter of undertaking is basically a guarantee from the domestic bank that they will pay the foreign bank in full, i.e., principal and interest.
On receipt of this letter of undertaking (LOU), foreign banks offer credit which can be used to pay the exporter. Usually, such letter of undertaking (LOU) is given only if the importer provides a significant amount of margin money to the domestic bank. The fraud done by Nirav Modi was that he had bribed bank officials to illegally obtain letters of undertaking (LOU) without paying and margin money. This basically amounted to an unsecured loan at very low-interest rates.
For instance, if Punjab National Bank issues a letter of undertaking (LOU) to Mr. Nirav Modi, he can then take it to the Hong Kong branch of HSBC bank and obtain credit. This credit can then be used to pay suppliers. Nirav Modi and exporter are no longer relevant to this transaction. In the end, Punjab National Bank now owes money to HSBC!
A letter of undertaking is a short-term credit which expires in 45 to 90 days. This scam has been going on for seven years! This is because each time these bills became due, they were rolled over. This means that new letters of undertaking (LOU) were issued and the money obtained from them was used to make payments for the old letters of undertaking (LOU).
The nature of the fraud becomes even more bizarre when the transaction that Nirav Modi was entering came to light. A prima facie look at the details shows that Mr. Modi was paying off himself with these transactions. As a result, he was basically swindling money from Punjab National Bank to his own account.
Most of the companies that the payments were made to belonged to Dubai or Hong Kong. These countries are known to allow set up of companies without too many background checks. These companies which were party to millions of dollars of transactions are notoriously opaque. Most of them do not even have a website and very few of these entities held money in their own accounts. As soon as they received the payments, they used a complex web of entities to funnel money. The final beneficiary of these transactions has not been determined. However, it would be safe to assume that it would be Mr. Nirav Modi.
This mega scam also brings in to question the strength of the systems being used by the banks. How could the banks not be aware of a scam which was happening in their backyard for seven long years? There are two major points to consider:
To sum it up, this scam will make matters even worse for Indian banks who are already reeling under the pressure of non-performing assets. The public confidence has taken a beating and Punjab National Bank is almost facing a bank run.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *