Role of Participants in a Group Discussion
The Group discussion is a task, which is generally aimed at understanding and evaluating candidate’s behavior in a group. Through this method, interviewers can compare and assess a candidate’s knowledge, communication, and mental strength. It is quite obvious through the name that Group discussion involves more than one members and it happens within a group. There could be different kind of participants in the group in terms of the roles that they play. Some of them are:
Starting point: You will notice that in the group, there will be some member who likes to initiate. One who is confident enough to start the discussion and set the tone right at the very first beginning is called the initiator. This position is a bit risky. If you are the one who is starting the discussion you have to be extra conscious. But do not think that if you have begun the discussion, you will keep your mouth shut during the whole conversation. You have to be active throughout the discussion.
Clear Facts: Few members of the group will be data driven. They provide precise data and facts and support their statement with statistics. They provide all the data in a logical manner and make their point stronger with facts. But it is also true that with only data you cannot win a discussion. You have to believe in those figures and put your mind enough to interpret it well. And yes...all your facts should be clear and truthful.
Controller: Some members in the group like to control the discussion. They think whatever they are saying should be approved by others as well which may or may not be the case. Others in the group can very well disagree to the point you are putting forth.
Moderate Referee: This category of the people acts as a coordinator. They ensure that each member gets sufficient time and chance to speak. When an argument gets heated up, they try to keep them calm and bring to a normal discussion by helping others putting across their words. This person is generally a good listener but might not be taken very favorably by others lest he should take all the leadership.
Born Leaders: They are born to lead. They do not have to put in much effort to lead a team. Their voice, their calm head, their gestures say it all. They do not fall in the trap of arguing rather support their points by strong logic, facts, and adequate examples. They have the ability to manage the flow of discussion and give it a right direction. Towards the end, a leader summarizes the entire discussion and squeeze out the conclusion.
Provocative: This person considers himself All in All. They give orders to others in the group and want everyone to act according to them. Sometimes they are annoying and provoke others with a high pitch or irritating voice. They eat up time of others by saying something which is not so relevant to the topic. They are poor listener and cannot comprehend what other’s points are.
Fault Finder: There are some group members who intentionally find fault in everything that the other person is saying. They have objection on anything and everything about other’s pint of view. They criticize almost every other point.
Followers: This is just contrary to the above-mentioned category – fault finder or criticizer. This category of people generally agree and support other’s point. They show their agreement by nodding their head or with some other gesture which normally means that they cannot agree more to the point. This kind of people generally do not score well as they do not show their own significant points and logics and merely depend on other’s views
Question Mark: This kind of people, always question others. He/she sometimes irritate other group members by questioning even for a simple understood fact. Rather than putting their own opinions, they tend to interrogate and raise a question in other’s points.
Stopwatch: These kinds of people are quite interesting to observe. During the discussion, they just do not get swayed by the flow of topic, rather keep a check on every other aspect, such as how much time has passed, how much time is still left, who all have had the chance to give their opinions and who have not, etc. They are keen to maintain the order and dignity. But it is better for these category people to come up with their own impactful views.
Aggressive: These members easily get annoyed and get antagonistic at times. They care less about other’s points, sentiments, feelings, and values. They attack verbally in their counterparts and harsh in their tone.
Audience/Viewer: They do not have their own substantial views and opinions. They hardly speak up and hardly make any difference. They just see and listen what others are speaking and never put their own views forward.
Indecisive: This category of people are unlikely to get selected as they are very much indecisive and having a fickle mind. They sometimes contradict their own words and statements. They are unable to express their ideas in an organized manner. They also get too emotional during the conversation and unnecessarily divert the topic from the main point. They agree or disagree with anyone and everyone.
Capturer: This kind of people record every point what others are saying. They take down notes and facts, details, etc. They can be referred later on when someone in the group has forgotten any point.
The Settler: They can be referred as Harmonizer and can find a mid-way of any problem. They avoid extremes and contribute in releasing tension within the group when an argument heats up.
Gist Maker: This defines the position as someone who summarized the entire discussion and draws some valid conclusion through the topic of group discussion.
Blockhead: This kind of group members does not take any initiative to present their views. They are lacing innovative or rather any ideas, opinions and logical views. They do not contribute any positively to the group.
Each of these roles is a part of a Group discussion and plays an important role within that. Their behavior and the role they are playing can talk a lot about their personality, mindset and their thinking.
- Strategies for Professionals
- How to Develop a Long Term Perspective
- Summer Internships in Business Schools
Authorship/Referencing - About the Author(s)
The article is Written By “Prachi Juneja” and Reviewed By Management Study Guide Content Team. MSG Content Team comprises experienced Faculty Member, Professionals and Subject Matter Experts. We are a ISO 2001:2015 Certified Education Provider. To Know more, click on About Us. The use of this material is free for learning and education purpose. Please reference authorship of content used, including link(s) to ManagementStudyGuide.com and the content page url.
- Organizational Career Development
- Importance of Career Development
- Designing Career Development Systems
- Benefits of Career Development System
- Components of Career Development
- Objectives of Career Development
- Career Development Issues in Teams
- Mentoring and Career Development
- Career Management
- Career Program Effectiveness
- Implications of Workplace Changes
- Organizational Assessment Programs
- Benefits of Formal Succession Planning
- Career Programs for Special Groups
- Hiring Couples & Relocation Assistance
- Career Personality Tests
- Career Ladders and Career Paths
- Employment Counselling
- Invest in Yourself Continuously
- Role of Organization in Self Improvement
- Role of Mentors in Career Development
- Some Tips for Fresh Graduates
- Tips for Graduates Entering Corporates
- What do Recruiters look for ?
- Tips for New Employees
- Changing Jobs Mid-Career
- Executive Management Programs
- Niche Management Programs
- Business Schools in the West & East
- Reinvent Yourself During Your Career
- Tips to Prepare for the Future
- Preparing Employees for the Future
- The Importance of Networking
- Industry Academia Collaborations
- Choosing the Right Business School
- Choosing Electives & Optional Courses
- Strategies for Professionals
- How to Develop a Long Term Perspective
- Summer Internships in Business Schools
- Rising Cost of Student Education
- Lowering the Education Costs in America
- Top MBA Colleges in India
- Role of Personal Development in Career Growth
- Steps in Personal Development Planning Process
- Executive Management Programs and Part Time Management Programs
- For those Nearing their Forties: How to Plan for your Second Half of Career and Life ?
- Lateral Placements and Some Strategies for those with Work Experience in Business Schools
- Why Professionals and Students Must Invest in Specialized Skills
- Skills are a Key Ingredient of Success in Contemporary Organizations
- How to Deal with Envy at Workplace ?
- Career Choices for the Present Times
- Impact of the Slowdown on those beginning their careers
- Skilling the Workforce to Make them Employable and Contribute to Economic Growth
- What is Linkedin and Why Having a Linked in Profile is Important
- How to Use the Summary Section in LinkedIn
- How to Manage Skills and Endorsements on Linkedin
- Gathering Recommendations and Getting Endorsed
- Joining Groups on Linkedin
- How to Project Yourself as a Brand by Using Strong Keywords and Updating the Profile Periodically
- Do’s and Don’ts of LinkedIn
- What is Group Discussion and How is it Different from a Debate
- Objectives of Conducting a Group Discussion
- Importance of Active Listening and Asking Clarifications in a Group Discussion
- Non Verbal Cues and its Importance in Group Discussion
- Phases in a Group Discussion: Introduction, Central Group Discussion and Summarization
- Role of Participants in a Group Discussion
- How Open Minded are You in a Group Discussion
- Student Loans and the Rising Cost of Useless Degrees
- Problem of Unsustainable Student Debt and How to Manage it ?
- Some Things to Consider When Choosing Off-Beat or Non-Mainstream Careers
- The Dilemma Facing Students and Professionals: Generalization or Specialization ?
- Tips for Professionals on Making Smart Career Moves during your Working Life
- Tips and Suggestions for Those Wishing to Enter Creative Professions
- Why Aspiring and Working Professionals Must Learn to Balance Ambition with Realism
- Career Advice for Those Over 40: Averting a Midlife Crisis and Finding Meaning in Work
- Current Employment Trends and Their Implications for Business, Society, and Individuals
- Some Investment Lessons and Advice for Professionals in the Age of the Gig Economy
- Designing and Implementing an Effective Work from Home Policy
- How Self Learning can help you be Ahead of the Curve in a Fast Changing World
- Why Reskilling Might be the Solution to Avoiding Job Losses from Automation and Robots
- The Need for Professionals and Experts to be Independent in Highly Polarized Times
- Income Sharing Agreement: An Answer to Student Debt?
- Transitioning From College to the Corporate World: Challenges and Approaches
- Should Corporates Make Work from Home Arrangements Permanent or Temporary?
- How the Covid Pandemic has altered the Notions of Work, Education, and Employment
- HRM Strategies for the Post Covid Era and the New Normal of Virtual Workplaces
- What is Career Path Mapping and Why Organizations Gain from Mapping Career Paths
- Does Academic Excellence Guarantee Professional Success or It Just Gives a Head Start?
- Why the Future of Learning is Virtual and How to Prepare for Online Education Models
- The Myth of the 8 Hour Workday! Why we need a New Approach to Productivity
- Return to Office Mandates in America