Arguments against Tax Competition
February 12, 2025
In terms of products and service coverage, the commercial banking ecosystem is much larger than the retail banking ecosystem. Corporations have a wide variety of business needs and commercial banks being their financial partners are expected to take care of these needs. In this article, we will have a closer look at the various categories […]
The average person believes that they are legally allowed to make any investment that a rich person can. However, this is not true in America, and this is certainly not true in many parts of the developed world. The reality is that the average American population is only legally allowed to purchase securities which are […]
How Dire is the Bad Debts Problem in Indian Banks In recent months, the news reports about India’s bad debts problems have been appearing almost on a daily basis. With the ballooning NPAs or Non Performing Assets (the term used to refer to debts owed to banks going sour), the Central government is grappling with […]
Equity valuation is about guessing what the value of an organization is expected to be a decade from now or an even bigger time horizon. Obviously, the financial future, just like future in general is difficult to predict. However, in equity valuation, one cannot proceed further until some assumptions are made about the future. Every […]
The discipline of economics is generally valid for all industries across the world. This is because the basic fundamental economic principles of demand, supply, and free market are applicable to almost all industries in the world. There are only a few industries where these economic principles are not really applicable. The sporting industry is one […]
America has been the hub of financial and entrepreneurial activity ever since the end of World War 2. However, over the past few years, the number of corporations that are using America as their base has been steadily declining. This is because of the unfavorable tax policies in America.
America is the only country in the world that combines a high tax rate with an international tax system. This means that the American government reserves the right to tax all the profits of an American corporation regardless of where they are generated and that too at very high rates! It is true that America is a big market, and companies are, in many ways, dependent upon it. However, then too, the tax policies are just too restrictive. This is the reason that companies in America use a wide variety of strategies to reduce their tax liabilities. Some of these strategies have been mentioned in this article.
In the 1980s, 18 out of the top 20 companies in the world were incorporated in America. However, now only 8 out of the top 20 companies are incorporated there. Companies like Burger King have famously moved their headquarters out of America. The reason behind this is that there are several companies such as Ireland which are providing a better corporate tax regime. The tax regime is better in general. However, these countries provide special incentives to companies that move their headquarters to their country. This is because the worldwide revenues are taxed in headquarters. Therefore the tax base increases, and the country can earn more tax revenue with a lower tax rate.
For instance, if a company generates profits in France and pays 15% tax there and the tax rate in the United States is 21%, then the American government will give credit for the 15% and only charge balance 6% tax. However, if another country, let’s say Japan charges a 30% tax, then America will not take any additional tax since 30% is already greater than 21%.
Corporations use this strategy to lower the overall tax rate. They time the movement of profits from low and high-income companies in such a way that the average of the tax paid in foreign countries almost equals the domestic tax rate. Blending income helps reduce further tax liability in the United States.
Hence, if a company can delay the repatriation, it can also delay the taxation indefinitely. This helps companies bottle up their profits and move them in a year when the company is experiencing losses.
Generally, an economic downturn comes every ten years or so. This is when the sales and profits of the company take a hit. If the company is facing a loss, it can repatriate some of the profits stored abroad. Even after these additional profits, the company will still break even or be under the taxation threshold. As a result, they will not be taxed and will be able to sneak in some of the stored profits tax-free!
Sometimes, the entire expense can be written off in the year in which it was done. This helps lower the tax base and hence the tax payable. Multinational companies use this provision to evade taxes. This is done by concentrating all the research and development activities in America. However, when the R&D team does come up with a breakthrough, it is used by all subsidiaries in different countries to generate a profit. The worldwide research expenses are just accumulated in one place in order to lower the American tax liability.
Bonds are issued and sold to the subsidiary itself. As a result, when coupon payments are made, the interest payment reduces the taxes payable in America, which is a low tax company. However, it increases income in another country. This leads to higher profits in another country. Once again, these profits are stored in subsidiaries abroad and can be deferred indefinitely by avoiding repatriation.
The bottom line is that American corporations undertake a lot of shenanigans. If the government were to rationalize the tax rate, a lot of this would stop, and the revenue generated by America may actually end up increasing. This argument has been the main reason behind Donald Trump’s rationalization of corporate tax rates.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *