The Link between Credit Growth and Real Estate Bubbles
February 12, 2025
Slowdown in China There has been a noticeable slowdown in the Chinese economy over the last few months. Coupled with a draining of the excess liquidity that was introduced into the economy through massive monetary stimulus in the wake of the global economic crisis, the Chinese economy suddenly looks vulnerable. Added to this is the […]
It is a common belief amongst the general population that labor unions work in the interest of the laborers. In fact, they believe that the power that collective bargaining gives these workers is probably the only thing that prevents their exploitation at the hands of greedy corporations. They had all heard about the history of […]
Gross domestic product (GDP), this is a term which is familiar to pretty much anybody who has ever read any newspaper. This number is considered by many to be the most important indicator of the state of the economy. However, how little clarity we have on the subject is remarkable. The average public is not […]
The GDP system has found several criticisms. However, none of the criticisms have been as apparent as an unusual phenomenon called “ghost cities” and “ghost towns” which have cropped up all across China. The sheer wastage and diversion of resources to non productive purposes to meet the government’s targets for GDP growth is apparent in […]
Green GDP In the search for a better system to account for our economy, researchers have looked at various options. We explored the GDP option and the sustainability analysis option in the past few articles. However, as we have seen both these systems are at odds with each other and it seems like there is […]
Real estate investments are known for fancy financing schemes. The right financing can make any real estate investment very lucrative whereas the wrong financing can end up giving disastrous results. Real estate developers have started using several different types of financing schemes to woo wary home buyers in the time of an industry slowdown. One of these schemes that are being extensively used is called the subvention scheme. A large number of first-time buyers are using this scheme to acquire their dream home. However, they are not aware of the many pitfalls of this type of financing.
In this article, we will explain how the subvention scheme has the potential to entrap prospective home buyers and cause grave financial harm to them.
In case of subvention schemes, the buyer pays the margin money. The bank disburses the entire loan amount and credits it to the developer on the very same day. The developer gets paid in full at the very same time! In return, the builder agrees to pay the interest accrued on loan to the bank on behalf of the borrower. Hence, the entire money is received upfront by the developer whereas the buyer owns nothing more than an agreement.
On the other hand, construction linked payment plans are when the developer is given fixed sums of money on the completion of certain milestones, i.e., slabs. The way these payments are defined can have a huge impact on the behavior of the builders. If the majority of the payments are given before possession, it is likely that the builder will delay possession. However, a lot of construction linked payment plans give a lot of weightage to possession and close to 25% of the payment is released after possession is provided by a builder.
It is absurd that builders are resorting to borrowing money on account of individuals even though businesses are given money at a lower rate of interest. Mainly the real estate business has assets that can be mortgaged to unlock the cash required to complete the project. Hence they should have access to credit at a lower rate than individuals.
However, it needs to be understood that most developers have heavy debt burdens. Their balance sheets already carry a lot of debt. Banks are not willing to offer more debt until they charge a very high rate of interest. It is therefore in the interest of the builder to borrow money on account of the buyer. The bank will not give the builder a lower rate of interest. However, they may offer the same to buyers depending on their credit rating.
Developers are not opting for subvention schemes. They are being forced into these schemes by banks who wouldn’t lend out to them. The question that arises is, if banks think it is too risky to invest in these real estate projects, then why is it that individual buyers think otherwise.
Maybe, the whole concept of subvention schemes is based on the ignorance of the individual home buyer.
Some major disadvantages of the subvention scheme are as follows:
The best way to buy a home is to avoid these complicated financing deals. Good old-fashioned financing has been tried and tested for decades and provides a fair opportunity to both parties involved.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *