Arguments against Tax Competition
February 12, 2025
Over the years, the sporting business has quietly metamorphosized into a big business. The amount of money changing hands in the sports business today would have been considered unthinkable even a few years ago. It is common for franchises to be valued in billions of dollars. Star players also make millions of dollars while playing […]
The field of commercial banking is undergoing many technological changes simultaneously. Open banking is one such technological change. Open banking is unique in the sense that this change has been initiated by regulators in most parts of the world. Generally, technological changes are adopted by commercial banks themselves with a view to increasing their productivity […]
Financial resources are scattered across the economy. This is the reason that there is a need for a financial system that can enable the timely deployment of these resources across different parts of the economy at the right time. A well-functioning financial system is supposed to perform several functions. Some of these functions have been […]
The net present value (NPV) is the most important concept in corporate finance. It is on the basis of this concept that investment decisions are made or not made. It is on the basis of this concept that stocks and bonds are valued. Thus, it is an absolute imperative for any student of corporate finance […]
Setting up a startup company can require a lot of paperwork. It is common for startup founders to spend a lot of their time and effort putting these papers in order. It may seem like a mundane chore and even counterproductive. However, the reality is that the company needs to have all its legal documents […]
The modern world is globalized. This means that free movement of goods, services, people as well as capital is allowed across the globe. This has important implications for governments. A globalized system means that tax systems can no longer work in a vacuum. The tax systems are continuously interacting with other tax systems, whether the governments like it or not. The relationship between the tax systems can be one of competition or one of co-operation.
In the previous couple of articles, we have discussed about tax competition, its benefits, and drawbacks. At the present moment, tax competition is the most prevalent system in the world. However, many organizations are trying hard to bring about tax co-operation as well. In this article, we will have a look at the other alternative i.e., tax co-operation.
Many large and influential countries of the world are fed up, losing tax revenues to developing nations who are willing to offer multinationals a better deal. This is the reason they are trying to co-operate amongst one another and form a group of countries. The basic premise here is that multinational corporations have more bargaining power when they deal with one single country. However, if nations bargain collectively as a block, then they can force multinationals into a truce. Some of the salient features of tax co-operation have been written below.
The stated benefit of tax co-operation is that it will put an end to all the non-productive activities which companies have to undertake in order to evade tax. There will be no need to hire expensive accounting and legal firms in order to find loopholes in tax systems. Also, governments will be able to better plan their expenditures since their revenues will be somewhat stable.
However, tax co-operation also has many disadvantages, some of which have been listed below:
Information Sharing: The governments of the world are simultaneously moving towards tax co-operation and privacy laws. Tax co-operation is a basic infringement on privacy laws. This is because it depends upon the government extensively sharing information with other countries with or without the consent of the corporation involved.
Equitable Share: Proponents of tax co-operation state that nearly 50% of the global trade nowadays happens between related companies. Hence, multinationals are able to evade taxes by using transfer pricing. The proposal is that going forward, all the legal entities owned by a multinational should be taxed as one single group. After the taxes are collected, they should be shared between participating countries. The problem is that it is impossible to determine the proportion in which participating countries should share the revenue. Regardless of which parameter is chosen, some countries will always believe that they are receiving a smaller share.
Cartelization: Tax co-operation seems like a euphemism for a tax cartel. Just like cartels, the intention of these governments is to gain monopoly power over other economic entities. Once they do so, they will have no incentive to be efficient or prudent. European governments are already known for wasteful expenditure. Tax co-operation will only exacerbate the problem instead of solving it.
Loss of Autonomy: Lastly, the idea of tax co-operation only sounds good until the external environment is conducive. Once a recession hits, every government will be on its own. In such cases, the incentive to break away from the cartel will be very high. Hence, the idea of tax co-operation relies on the collective action of many parties with varied interests. It is unlikely that such a system would sustain over the long run.
The bottom line is that tax co-operation is still a concept. Countries have not been able to implement it since it seems to be far-fetched. Competition is the natural state between multiple parties. There are very few examples of long-standing multilateral examples in the world.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *