The Chinese Pension System
February 12, 2025
Apple Inc. is the largest and the most profitable company in the entire world. However, of late, it has also found itself in the middle of several lawsuits. The company has been facing a legal battle with Spotify of late. However, none of the legal battles even come close to the legal drama that is […]
Creating the maximum possible shareholder value had always been the cornerstone of capitalism. All economic theories had always been aimed at maximizing long term shareholder value. However, in the late 90s and early 2000’s, this situation changed rapidly. Instead of reporting annually, companies had to report their profits or losses on a quarterly basis. It […]
Financial models are used by corporations almost every day. These models help while making several key strategic decisions. For instance, if a company plans to enter a new country or even take over another company, it is likely that it will create a financial model first. This model is a way of generating “What-If” information […]
In the previous article, we learned about the three financial statements. We also learned how income statements and balance sheets are backward-looking financial statements. We also understood that the budget is the only forward-looking financial statement in the personal finance domain. It is the only statement that can be used to prevent economic mistakes from […]
It is common knowledge in the investing world that almost 90% of the start-up companies which come into existence shut down within the first couple of years. However, it is also assumed that if a company is able to gain funding from professional investors, its chances of surviving become astronomically high. This is because it […]
Pension funds are one of the most regulated financial investment vehicles in the world. Pension funds all over the world are subject to various types of restrictions. These restrictions affect every part of the pension funds’ operations. The governance mechanisms have to rigorously be followed while funds are being taken in, invested, accounted for, and disbursed.
However, it also needs to be understood that pension funds all over the funds are not subject to the same type of regulation. The rules that govern the regulation of pension funds are quite different in almost every country. However, these rules emanate from two basic systems of pension governance.
These two systems are called the “prudent person rule” and the “quantitative restrictions system” In this article, we will have a closer look at these two systems of pension governance.
The prudent person principle is a set of rules which attempts to control the way in which decisions are made when it comes to pension fund investments. This means that the regulations do not require the trustees to have exceptional expertise or to follow a particular schedule. Rather the trustees are expected to behave in a manner that would enable them to preserve the capital which grows at a reasonable rate.
The prudent person rule does not levy any explicit restrictions on the type of investments that the fund managers choose. However, since they are legally required to be prudent, it is safe to assume that questionable investments such as penny stocks or cryptocurrency are not considered an option while making investment decisions. The prudent person principle provides a lot of freedom to trustees and fund managers while expecting them to be rational and ethical.
As a part of the quantitative restriction method, there is an explicit list of instruments that pension fund managers can choose from. There is a clear and tangible demarcation between the types of investments that are allowed and the ones that are not allowed. Also, there are rules governing the types of financial instruments which are allowed.
There is a maximum percentage of the funds in the portfolio that can be allocated towards asset classes. For instance, governments can mandate that not more than 40% of the fund’s assets can be held in equity assets. This means that the portfolio managers will be required to continuously rebalance their portfolios to ensure that they are complying with the law.
It has been observed that countries that have relatively well-developed economies and financial markets choose the prudent person rule as their regulatory principle. However, countries that are not as developed rely more on the quantitative restrictions system. This choice is governed by certain factors which have been listed below:
For instance, if a large number of pension funds follow the defined benefit method, then the government is more likely to impose a quantitative restriction system. This is because the government indirectly becomes responsible for guaranteeing pension payments. On the other hand, if defined contribution plans are commonly followed, then the government is more likely to follow the prudent person rule.
Hence, it can be said that there are two main types of governance systems when it comes to the regulation of pension funds. The choice of the governance system depends upon a wide variety of factors. This choice has a significant implication on the performance of pension funds worldwide.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *