Comparative Public Administration
February 12, 2025
The trait model of leadership is based on the characteristics of many leaders – both successful and unsuccessful – and is used to predict leadership effectiveness. The resulting lists of traits are then compared to those of potential leaders to assess their likelihood of success or failure. Scholars taking the trait approach attempted to identify […]
We are now aware that reinsurance companies are created especially for taking up risk from other insurance companies. Most people believe that this is the end of the value chain. This means that the risk stays on the books of the reinsurance company till it is extinguished. However, this is not the case. Reinsurance companies […]
Firms often give loans or extend credit over extended periods of time. The credit extended may continue for years and even decades. It is possible for the management of the company to change during this period. It is also possible for the cash flow position of the company to change during this period. Hence, it […]
The Business Case for Agile Organisations Each age or era in business has its own defining method of doing business. If it was the top down bureaucratic model in the Industrial Era, it was the flatter organisational structure in the services age. Now, as we are on the cusp of the Fourth Industrial Revolution and […]
We had discussed how the OODA Loop or the Observe, Orient, Decision, Action loop works in helping to make better decisions. The first and the important thing to remember about the OODA loop is that it is mainly concerned about situations that involve split second decision making. Considering the fact that it was developed by […]
Public administration is like any other administration which is carried out in public interest. Before we dwell deeper into understanding public administration it would be beneficial to try and see how different authors have tried to define what administration is.
Marx defines administration as - Administration is determined action taken in pursuit of a conscious purpose. It is the systematic ordering of affairs and the calculated use of resources aimed at making those happen which one wants to happen.
Frederic k Lane defines administration as organizing and maintaining human and fiscal resources to attain a group’s goals.
A complete definition for public administration however is difficult to arrive at due to the sheer number of tasks that fall under it.
Some academicians argue that all the government related work falls into this category while other choose to argue that only the executive aspect of government functioning comprises of public administration.
We can also see how different authors have defined public administration:
According to L D White, Public administration consists of all those operations having for their purpose the fulfillment or enforcement of public policy.
On the other hand as per Woodrow Wilson public administration is a detailed and systematic application of law.
One can also say that public administration is nothing but the policies, practices, rules and regulation etc, in action.
Now can public administration be divorced from social and political systems?; certainly NOT and therefore emerged another definition provided by F A Nigro who argues that public administration is essentially a cooperative group effort in public setting.
Secondly, it covers all the three branches of government machinery, the executive, the legislative and the judicial.
He further added that since public administration plays a crucial role in formulation of policies therefore it is a part of the political process as well (for e.g. Bills and Acts).
Negro also said that public administration is different from private administration in numerous ways and that it interacts with various private groups and individuals in providing services to the community.
Also, on the nature of public administration there have been two popular views, one being the Integral view and the other one is the Managerial view.
The Integral view is all encompassing and consists of sum total of all managerial, clerical, technical and manual activities and employees form all levels. This view was endorsed by L D White and Dimock. It may differ from one agency to another depending on their sphere of work.
On the other hand the Managerial view, as the name suggests says that the public administration involves only the managerial activities. This view was supported by Simon, Smithburg, Thompson and Luther Gulick.
After having said that; the word administration itself is highly contextual, and may vary in meaning and definition from one organization to another.
So if you want to understand it from the context and setting of an organization, it can be roughly explained that; the top leadership or the Board decides the vision, mission, short and long term goals and the business unit heads then draw out action plans and create or reform processes, allot responsibilities, direct planning, get people on board and start working towards achieving those set goals as per defined guidelines.
So, the Board can be the Government and the Business Unit Heads and their teams can be the public administrators who are the implementers and actually the people who run the show.
In the next section we shall make an effort to understand whether public and private administrations are similar, different or are there any overlaps between the two.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *