Commonly Used Terms in Derivative Market
February 12, 2025
Over the years, the sporting business has quietly metamorphosized into a big business. The amount of money changing hands in the sports business today would have been considered unthinkable even a few years ago. It is common for franchises to be valued in billions of dollars. Star players also make millions of dollars while playing […]
Flipkart is amongst the largest unicorns in the Indian startup ecosystem. Wal-Mart is a known international retailer with revenues upwards of $400 billion. Both of these companies are formidable in their own fields. However, they are set to merge. Wal-Mart has valued Flipkart at $18 billion and is all set to complete the acquisition. This […]
In the previous article, we have already studied that all bankruptcies are not involuntary. In many cases, the shareholders and/or the management of the company make a conscious decision to file for bankruptcy. This happens because the benefits that may accrue as a result of filing bankruptcy are greater than the loss of reputation and […]
In the previous articles, we have already studied the difference between defined benefit plans and defined contribution plans. We now know that defined-benefit plans promise to pay the retiree a fixed nominal amount whereas defined contribution plans promise to pay the retirees the worth of their investment portfolios. There is a big difference between the […]
The average investor may be able to keep their thinking in check and save themselves from a lot of biases. However, they still might not be aware of or be able to manage some of the more advanced biases. The anchoring bias is one such bias. It affects the thinking of even the most sophisticated […]
After the banking crisis, the Indian capital markets are facing another dire situation. It has recently come to light that many mutual funds have been lending money to promoters of companies.
It needs to be understood that these loans are not being made to companies but rather to promoters of companies. The problem is that some of these loans may have turned bad. This is causing panic amongst mutual fund investors, many of whom had no idea that they had exposure to companies such as IL&FS and DHFL! In this article, we will have a closer look at the loans being sanctioned by fund houses as well their economic impact.
Many times promoters are in need of cash. Perhaps they want to expand their business or have to meet working capital requirements. However, after the NPA crisis, not many public sector banks are willing to lend money to corporations until they have a rock solid credit rating and also provide adequate collateral. Many banks do not accept equity shares as collateral.
This is where debt based mutual funds come in. These mutual funds do not have to adhere to regulations like banks have to. Hence, they are free to lend money to corporations or individuals if they are reasonably confident that they will be paid back.
Mutual funds often fund promoters by forming separate structures. They provide loans only against the shares of blue chip companies. Also, since shares are believed to be extremely volatile, they only finance up to 50% of the market value of the shares. At least in theory, this gives the lenders enough margin to cut their losses in the event of a downturn. It is also known that the securities work like margin loans. For instance, if the value of the collateral drops, then mutual funds have the right to insist on more shares or liquid securities. The idea is to avoid as much risk as possible.
The real reason why mutual funds lend to promoters is that they want to earn a higher return on their investment. Debt funds are under constant pressure to outperform their peers. Outperforming is not easy if the funds portfolio only consists of publicly traded securities. Promoters do not have a very high credit rating. Also, their collateral also fluctuates in value. This is the reason why they are willing to pay higher interest rates. In the past few years, this higher rate has been the reason that some funds have outperformed the others.
There is nothing inherently illegal or immoral about these promoter loans. However, it needs to be understood that these loans are actually quite risky. Hence, it is the responsibility of mutual funds to explain the risks to their investors. Some of the risks related to mutual funds have been listed down as follows.
Firstly, it signals to the markets that the promoter who happens to be an insider to the business is trying to exit it! Also, promoters own huge blocks of shares.
When these huge blocks are put on the market for sale, they tend to increase the supply without any corresponding increase in the demand. As a result, the price plummets rapidly. These scenarios may seem far-fetched but a few Indian mutual funds have found themselves stuck with promoter debt. They are being forced to enter into agreements with promoters since they cannot really afford to sell the debt without risking losing a significant part of their investment.
The bottom line is that mutual funds lending money to promoters is nothing new. However, given the current environment, there is unnecessary scaremongering over such loans. Mutual funds only need to make their investors aware that such loans may be riskier than others which is why they provide better returns too!
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *